Here is a complete list of all the Mystery Plants of the Month, initially researched by Tim Neal from back issues, and corrected from Roy's list
| 2009 | |
| Dec | Marsilea minuta |
| 2010 | |
| Jan | Cryptocoryne parva |
| March | Hydrotriche hottoniiflora |
| May | Lobelia cardinalis var small form |
| June | Staurogyne sp. "Tropica Round Leaf"/"Tropica 049"/"Low Grow" |
| Sep | Ludwigia glandulosa |
| Oct | Polygonum sp. 'kawagoeanum' |
| Nov | Ludwigia senegalensis |
| Dec | Anubias barteri var nana 'Petite' |
| 2011 | |
| Jan | Syngonanthus 'Belem' |
| Feb | Pogostemon erectus |
| March | Crinum calamistratum |
| April | Echinodorus vesuvius |
| May | Hygrophila pinnatifida |
| June | Hydrocotyle tripartita |
| Sep | Rotala sp. 'Green' |
| Oct | Bolbitis heudelotii 'small form' |
| Nov | Ludwigia x lacustris (Ludwigia previpes x palustris) |
| Dec | Cyperus helferi |
| 2012 | |
| Jan | Limnophila repens 'Mini' |
| Mar | Crepidomanes auriculatum |
| May | Staurogyne sp. 'Purple' |
| June | Hygrophila lancea |
| Sep | Cuphea anagalloidea |
| Oct | Bacopa madagascariensis |
| Dec | Hygrophila lancea |
| 2013 | |
| Feb | Limnophila "Wavy" |
| March | Bacopa salzmannii |
| May | Elatine triandra |
| June | Persicaria praetermissa |
| Sep | Hygrophila araguaia |
| Oct | Ranalisma rostrata |
| Dec | Pogostemon stellatus sp. 'Octopus' (actually P. quadrifolius) |
| 2014 | |
| Jan | Ludwigia inclinata var. verticillata 'Pantanal' |
| Feb | Myriophyllum sp. 'guyana' / 'mini' |
| March | Alternanthera reineckii var. 'Octopus' |
| May | Ludwigia brevipes |
| June | Rotala mexicana bangladesh |
| Sep | Alternanthera reineckii "mini" |
| Oct | Limnophila sp 'vietnam mini' |
| Dec | Eriocaulon setaceum (Type 3) |
| 2015 | |
| Jan | Bucephalandra 'Dark wave' |
| Feb | Hygrophila sp. 'Brown' / 'Thai' |
| March | Rotala "Hra"/"Gai Lai" |
| May | Bucephalandra 'Pygmaea' |
| June | Limnophila 'Guinea Broad Leaf' |
| Sep | Bucephalandra 'mini catherine' |
| Oct | Cryptocoryne becketti 'Petchii' |
| 2016 | |
| March | Cryptocoryne pontederifolia |
| May | Eriocaulon 'Vietnam' |
| June | Cryptocoryne nurii (Pahang Mutated) |
| Sep | Helanthium (Echinodorus) gabrieli |
| Oct | Rotala ramosior 'Sunset' |
| Dec | Tonina fluviatilis |
| 2017 | |
| Jan | Pogostemon 'Kimberley' |
| Feb | Rotala 'Butterfly' |
| Mar | Pogostemon 'Heidelberg' |